Overthinking is exhausting – what can I do about it?

A woman resting under a blanket on a sofa, with popcorn, drinks and a laptop on the coffee table
Overthinking is just exhausting. Do you replay conversations in your head, wondering, “Did I really say that?” Do you second-guess decisions you have made, thinking, “I shouldn’t have spent that much!” Perhaps your mind is full of endless to-do lists, or stuck in a loop of “could’ve, would’ve, should’ve”.

You are not alone

Such an exhausting pattern can however change, with time, understanding and support.
Everyone overthinks from time to time. Everybody. But for those who find themselves stuck and emotionally drained for hours, overthinking can become a learned habit that makes even small decisions feel overwhelming.
As a psychodynamic counsellor – a fancy name for a talking therapist – I gently help clients recognise that overthinking can often be a clever, complex way of protecting themselves from painful feelings.
So, what’s the problem with that?
Overthinking is, in fact, an unconscious defence mechanism. And that’s the brilliant bit. We don’t even know we’re doing it. A bit like yawning. But with overthinking, our mind automatically protects us from feelings or thoughts that would be too painful to face.

But overthinking isn’t like yawning; it’s worrying in circles

Consider this. Do you sometimes dread a weekday evening out with friends after work, secretly preferring the idea of curling up on the sofa and watching Netflix? Neither option is right or wrong. Staying in, for example, does no harm – unless your inner voice starts asking, “Should I have made the effort?” or “Will my friends still like me if I don’t go?” On the other hand, going out offers the chance to chat and laugh with friends you haven’t seen in a while.
Cue overthinking, self-doubt and mental exhaustion.

Courage is needed to tackle overthinking

I believe it takes courage to challenge this way of thinking. Overthinking is, ironically, the easy way out. It gives you something to do: looking for reassurance to validate a decision, such as “I won’t go out tonight, because I am tired.”
Feeling something, as opposed to thinking about it, is harder to deal with, because there usually isn’t a simple answer when a decision needs to be made.
The hope is that overthinking will make the feeling disappear. But this way of thinking rarely serves us well.
When clients live with difficult feelings like this on a regular basis, a collaborative approach in therapy is essential. A conversation is needed. For the client who has agonised over deciding between Netflix and an evening out with friends, our work would be to help find the words for those feelings.

“That’s all mumbo jumbo,” I might hear you cry

But this is where the real therapeutic work begins, and where some clients might begin to realise that they aren’t ready for therapy, or don’t want it. And that’s OK. You need to be ready and available to reflect on your feelings.

Change through conversation

If we can find words for our painful feelings, through conversation, those feelings can get a little smaller, a little less wobbly, and may stop relentlessly bossing us about.
The choice between the sofa and the pub is a neutral one. A night in watching TV invites rest: “I’m shattered and a bit ‘peopled out’ after a long week at work.” But then another part of you gets energy from seeing your friends as you unwind and have a much-needed laugh. Neither wish is wrong.
This is when ambivalence – wanting two things at the same time – can become bearable. Without words, the exhausting scenario becomes a fight you must win, and the overthinking begins again. With conversation, the problem can become “Part of me wants to stay in” and “Part of me wants to go out”, which is much easier to deal with.

You don't have to carry painful feelings on your own

The beauty of a therapeutic alliance – between counsellor and client – is that you don’t have to carry painful feelings alone, until, perhaps, you are able to bear them yourself.
Eventually, the feelings that prompted the overthinking may become less frightening and more manageable.
Finding words for our feelings helps us understand ourselves more deeply, which can help us move towards emotional wellbeing and a more satisfying life.

© 2026 Jamie Last Therapy